I've never seen Amanda F. Palmer in person, I've just heard her music. And I doubt that many have seen Neil Gaiman perform before. So I came in very much without knowing what to expect.
What I got was astounding -- the result of two people with so much talent they're not sure what to show us next, but whatever comes up is going to be brilliant. And brilliant it was. The dramatic offstage opening led into Amanda and Neil singing a prepared duet of the Donaldson/Kahn classic 'Makin' Whoopee', in joyous celebration of their recent marriage.
But they've married their talents too. Gaiman has apparently written songs (including the wry updated "I Google(TM) You"), and has begun singing them too. Palmer has cleverly chosen to keep the music intimate by performing all her numbers, mostly solo, on grand piano or ukelele. Her versatile voice and huge presence kept the audience engaged and energized.
I realize that this concert may never be repeated in anything like a similar form, but some of the other bits I remember and loved included:
Three unpublished Neil Gaiman spooky short stories, one in poem form, all read with sensitivity and spooky insistence. One perfect rendering of the blackly comic Derek & Clive "Jump". Amanda Palmer's brilliant piano-only improv version of Coin-Operated Boy. A comfy personal "Q&A" session that got unexpectedly personal.
And a message. Perhaps this message is frequently present at AFP concerts, or implicitly in Neil's stories, I haven't noticed. But their message is encapulated beautifully in Amanda's encore number, 'The Ukelele Anthem', and that message is 'Go thou and do likewise'. All their art is inclusive -- no matter how much talent and preparation is evident, it's obvious that they both think we, their listeners, can each do something equally marvellous, and they'd love for us each to do so.
I think I shall.